Analysis is Paralysis
In the contemporary pantheon of musical virtuosos, one name continues to resonate with unparalleled resonance: Jacob Collier. Heralded as a prodigy, polymath, and pioneer, Collier's oeuvre transcends the boundaries of conventional music, igniting a sonic renaissance that redefines our understanding of harmonic complexity.
Over the years spent immersed in his work, oscillating between awe and frustration (think Mozart/Salieri), constantly bi-polarized between inspiration and profound discouragement, I recently sought to exonerate myself from the burden of musical training and an analytical nature. My wife and I embarked on a journey to the illustrious Hollywood Bowl where before taking our seats, I removed my proverbial musician cap and patiently waited without preconceptions or expectation.
In the realm of music, harmony is often considered the backbone of composition. Complex musical harmony, characterized by intricate chord progressions, unconventional tonalities, and rich layers of sound, might seem daunting to many, especially to those without formal music training. Surprisingly, intricate harmony can sometimes be more easily digested by the layman than by the expert musician. In this blog, we will explore the reasons behind this phenomenon and why complex harmony can be more enjoyable for the average listener.
Emotional Resonance Over Technicality
For expert musicians, complex harmonic structures can be analyzed and appreciated on a technical level. They may focus on the theoretical aspects, like chord substitutions or modulations, which can sometimes distance them from the emotional core of the music. In contrast, the layman experiences music primarily on an emotional level. Complex harmony can evoke strong emotional responses without the need for technical analysis. It's the emotional impact that often resonates more deeply with the average listener.
Surprising and Novel Experiences
Complex harmony can introduce novel and unexpected sonic experiences. Laymen often revel in the surprise and delight of hearing something they've never encountered before. Expert musicians, conversely, might be more conditioned to anticipate certain harmonic progressions and find comfort in familiar patterns. The element of surprise in complex harmony can captivate the layman's attention and keep them engaged throughout the piece.
Aesthetic Appreciation Without Preconceptions
Expert musicians often carry the baggage of their musical education, which can sometimes lead to preconceived notions of what "good" or "correct" harmony should sound like. Laymen, on the other hand, approach music with a more open and unburdened perspective. They are free to appreciate the aesthetics of complex harmony without the weight of expectations, making them more receptive to unconventional and avant-garde musical choices.
Subliminal Enjoyment of Complexity
While laymen may not possess the theoretical knowledge to dissect complex harmonic structures, they can still enjoy the richness and depth that these harmonies add to the overall musical experience. Much like savoring a gourmet meal without knowing the intricacies of its preparation, laymen can relish complex harmony on a subconscious level, allowing the music to wash over them in a way that feels natural and unforced.
Complexity as a Catalyst for Engagement
Complex harmony can act as a catalyst for active listening among laymen. It encourages them to lean in, focus, and pay closer attention to the music, as they search for patterns or relish in the intricacies. This heightened level of engagement can lead to a more immersive and fulfilling listening experience.
Conclusion
Complex musical harmony, while often seen as the domain of expert musicians, possesses a unique allure that can be more readily accessible and enjoyable for the layman. The emotional resonance, surprising elements, freedom from preconceptions, subliminal appreciation, and enhanced engagement all contribute to making complex harmony a rich and fulfilling experience for those who may lack formal musical training.
Powered By Scotland Clothing LLC >>